Actually, I never watched any of the "Nightmare" movies (or "Friday the 13th" or "Halloween").

I'm really not quite sure what makes Carlyle attractive to me; he's not what you'd call conventionally handsome, after all... though I've never really been one for convention. I suppose if I sat down and analyzed the men I've found attractive over the years, I'd find some common features... but I'd have a hell of a time trying to analyze without drooling. ;-)